Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Greg Marchand's avatar

Bryan,

This landed with me in a real way.

I was talking with a friend yesterday about one of his employees. The guy’s headed back to Tennessee after two years on an ankle bracelet and probation. My friend’s worried he’ll slide right back into old behaviors.

What struck me is how quickly we move into fix mode — especially with men.

“Here’s what he needs to do.”

“Here’s how we can keep him from blowing it.”

Underneath that is the same thing you’re naming: we start treating people like broken machinery that needs the right part swapped out.

I told my friend straight: we can’t fix people. We can support them, we can walk with them, we can set boundaries — but we don’t get to rewire their insides. I personally believe only God and a willing heart can truly correct a person from the inside out. The rest of us are just fellow travelers, not mechanics of someone else’s soul.

And we do the same thing to ourselves first.

I catch myself there all the time. Mentally circling the same list:

The conversation I should’ve handled better,

the decision I can’t stop second-guessing,

the pattern I swear I “should” be past by now.

Somewhere along the line, I started seeing myself as a problem to be solved instead of a person to be known.

Like you said, a lot of us — especially men — are chasing some invisible standard:

A perfect job, a perfect car, an ideal wife, a perfect story.

We shine the outside of the vehicle and never lift the hood on the actual heart that’s driving it.

Perfection is a hallucination at best. And honestly, some things don’t need upgrading. There are times I’ve tried to “improve” something — a system, a plan, even a relationship dynamic — and later wished I’d just left it alone and brought a quieter heart into it instead.

In our men’s ministry, we’ve got a little phrase for this:

We call it “shoulding” on people.

If you say it out loud a couple of times, it takes on another tone we’re all familiar with. 😏

Point is — we load people up with “you should… you should… you should…” and pretty soon they’re buried under our expectations instead of grounded in their own calling. Same thing we do to ourselves. We should be on ourselves all day long and then wonder why we feel ashamed and never enough.

That’s why I loved the way you shifted the questions:

Not “How do I fix this?”

But “How do I work with this?”

Not “What’s wrong with me?”

But “What’s here in me?”

I’d add one more that I’ve been sitting with:

What is my heart focused on?

Because if my heart is obsessed with looking “fixed,” I’ll keep working against my humanity and the humanity of everyone around me. I’ll continue to treat myself, my team, and my family like projects on a workbench.

But if my heart is set on becoming more honest, more grounded, more whole — and if I trust that God does the deeper work in me and in others — then my flaws, my anxiety, my need for control, even my screw-ups become places I can work with instead of parts I have to rip out.

Your line about people who are most at ease not being the ones who finally fixed themselves, but the ones who stopped treating themselves like something broken — that hit home. I see that. The freest people I know are those who have dropped the illusion of “supposed to be further along” and just started living as they are, doing the best they can with the code they’re running, while letting God deal with what only He can touch.

Anyway, just wanted you to know your words met me right where I’ve been living lately — in my own head, with my own lists, watching people I care about wobble on the edge of old patterns and wanting to save them.

Maybe the real work is this:

not to fix ourselves or anyone else into some perfect configuration,

but to stand there, fully human, heart awake, and say,

“I’m here. I’m learning to work with what’s in me. I’ll walk beside you while you do the same — and I’ll trust God with the part neither of us can fix.”

Appreciate you putting language to this, brother.

It helped me reframe some things I’ve been carrying for a long time.

G~

Expand full comment
John Cook's avatar

Truly insightful. Changing negative into positive. Accepting on flaws in ourselves as others as evolution. Well-said.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts